iFightDebt · Maryland Consumer Defense
Surprise Billing and the No Surprises Act: A Federal Shield
You did everything right, went to an in-network hospital, and still got a bill from a doctor you never chose. Federal law may say you do not owe it.
You called your insurance company. You confirmed the hospital was in network. You paid your copay at the desk. Then the envelopes started coming - not from the hospital, but from doctors whose names you do not recognize. An anesthesiologist. A radiology group. An emergency physician staffing company. Each one wants the difference between what it charged and what your insurance paid, and the total is more than you make in a month.
Here is the worst case, said plainly. Ignore those bills and they can be sold or assigned to a collection agency, damage your credit, and eventually land you in District Court. Pay them in a panic and you may hand over money that federal law says you never owed - and getting it back is always harder than never paying it.
The better news is that this exact situation is what Congress targeted with the No Surprises Act, which took effect on January 1, 2022. For most Marylanders with private insurance, the most common surprise bills are now illegal.
What a Surprise Bill Is
Doctors and hospitals that are in network have signed a contract with your insurer agreeing to accept its payment, plus your share, as payment in full. Out-of-network providers have not signed that contract. Before 2022, they could bill you for the gap - a practice called balance billing. When that balance bill comes from someone you never chose and did not know was out of network, it is a surprise bill.
The problem was never carelessness by patients. You cannot pick your anesthesiologist while you are unconscious, and you cannot shop for an emergency room in the back of an ambulance.
“A surprise bill is not a verdict. It is a claim - and you are allowed to make them prove it.”
What the No Surprises Act Protects
If you have coverage through an employer, the Maryland Health Connection marketplace, or an individual plan, the federal law generally protects you in three situations:
- Emergency care. Most emergency services are protected even at an out-of-network hospital or freestanding ER, and even without prior approval. You owe only what you would have owed in network - your normal copay, coinsurance, and deductible.
- Out-of-network providers at an in-network facility. If you have surgery at an in-network hospital or surgery center, the anesthesiologist, radiologist, pathologist, lab, assistant surgeon, hospitalist, or intensivist cannot balance bill you for covered services, even if they are out of network.
- Air ambulance. Out-of-network air ambulance bills are limited to your in-network share.
The federal law matters most for people in employer self-insured plans - the kind most large employers offer - because Maryland's state insurance laws generally do not reach those plans. Medicare, Medicaid, TRICARE, and VA patients already had their own protections before 2022.
The Consent Form Trap
For some scheduled, non-emergency care, an out-of-network provider may hand you a notice and consent form asking you to give up your surprise billing protections and agree to pay more. That is allowed in limited cases - for example, when you deliberately choose an out-of-network surgeon and are told the cost in advance.
It is not allowed for everything. For emergency medicine, anesthesiology, pathology, radiology, neonatology, assistant surgeons, hospitalists, intensivists, and diagnostic services such as lab work, a provider at an in-network facility can never ask you to waive your protections. If someone slides a waiver across the counter for one of those services, do not sign it, and keep a copy if you already did.
If You Are Uninsured or Paying Cash
The law also protects people who have no insurance or who choose not to use it. When you schedule care, tell the provider you are not using insurance. The provider or facility must then give you a written good faith estimate of what the care will cost.
Keep every good faith estimate you receive. Without it, the dispute door is closed.
What to Do When the Bill Arrives
Start with your insurer's Explanation of Benefits - the statement that shows what was billed, what the plan paid, and what it says you owe. If a provider's bill asks for more than the patient-responsibility line on that statement for a protected service, you are likely looking at a violation, not a debt.
If you have insurance, you do not use the $400 dispute. Instead, you appeal through your plan if it processed the claim wrong, and you file a complaint. Complaints can go to the federal No Surprises Help Desk at 1-800-985-3059, the Maryland Insurance Administration at 1-800-492-6116, or the Health Education and Advocacy Unit of the Maryland Attorney General's Consumer Protection Division at 1-877-261-8807. If a debt collector is already calling about a surprise bill, or it shows up on your credit report, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau takes complaints too.
And if the bill is from a Maryland hospital, do not forget the state's hospital financial assistance rules we covered earlier this month. A bill can be both a surprise bill and one you qualify to have reduced or forgiven.
- Lay the provider's bill next to your Explanation of Benefits. Circle any amount above your in-network share for emergency care, air ambulance, or out-of-network doctors at an in-network facility. Do not pay the circled amount while you sort it out.
- Call the provider's billing office, say the words "No Surprises Act," and ask them to reprocess the bill. Write down the date, the name, and what they said. If they refuse, file complaints with the No Surprises Help Desk and the Maryland Insurance Administration.
- If you were uninsured or paid cash, find your good faith estimate today. If the bill is $400 or more over it, mark the 120-day deadline from the bill date on your calendar and file the dispute well before it.
Nobody can promise every medical bill will disappear. Some are owed, and pretending otherwise helps no one. But a surprising number of the bills that send Marylanders into panic are bills the law already says they do not have to pay. If a collector or a lawsuit is already in the picture, that is the moment to get a lawyer involved - before you pay a dime.
Related articles
Medical Debt and Your Credit Report — The 365-Day Rule
Does medical debt show up on your credit report in Maryland? The 365-day rule, Maryland's 2025 law, what it does not fix, and how to dispute errors.
Negotiating a Medical Bill Down — Real Strategies That Work
How to negotiate a medical bill in Maryland: financial assistance, itemized bills, payment plans, and what to do before a collector calls. By Amir Guerami, The Guerami Law Firm, LLC.
Maryland's Hospital Financial Assistance Law: The Charity Care You May Already Qualify For
Maryland hospital financial assistance explained: who qualifies for free or reduced-cost care, the 240-day window after your first bill, the State Uniform Financial Assistance Application, and how to appeal a denial. By Amir Guerami, The Guerami Law Firm, LLC.
Reading a Hospital Bill — What You Are Actually Being Charged For
How to read a Maryland hospital bill: your legal right to an itemized statement, why Maryland's all-payer rates mean the price is not the argument, the free and reduced-cost care thresholds, the 240-day windows that matter, and the separate doctor bills that catch people off guard. By Amir Guerami, The Guerami Law Firm, LLC.
Related practice area: Debtor Protection